Marine insurers eye 5% premium hikes in 2027: Lockton
Protection and indemnity clubs recorded $177m in underwriting losses in 2025/26.
Protection and indemnity (P&I) clubs are expected to raise premiums by an average of 5% in 2027 as geopolitical tensions and rising reinsurance costs put pressure on underwriting results, according to Lockton.
The broker's 2026 P&I Market Report warned that clubs could face greater financial pressure if investment returns weaken, as they have relied on investment income to offset underwriting losses in recent years.
The average combined ratio of International Group P&I clubs improved to 102.5% in 2025/26, from 104.9% a year earlier.
However, the 12 clubs still recorded a combined underwriting loss of $177m, averaging $15m per club.
The cumulative underwriting loss over the past three years reached $331m, compared with $98m at the 2024/25 renewal.
Investment returns helped offset these losses, with the clubs recording an average return of 8%, or $95m, in 2025/26. Group-wide investment returns totalled $2.63b over the past three years, marking the third consecutive year in which investment income supported underwriting results.
However, weaker investment markets could remove this financial cushion and increase pressure on clubs to improve underwriting performance to maintain or strengthen their S&P credit ratings.
Geopolitical disruption is also affecting shipowners and charterers operating between Asia and Europe, where rerouting and longer transit times can increase voyage costs and create uncertainty over war-risk insurance premiums.
The report highlighted temporary cancellation notices, revised exclusions and the expansion of designated high-risk areas in the war-risk insurance market. Sanctions imposed under different international regimes have also created compliance challenges for shipowners and insurers.
Sung Wook Han, regional head of marine for Asia at Lockton, said reinsurance costs, war-risk developments and changing regulatory requirements would remain key considerations for Asian shipowners preparing for the 2027 renewal season.
He said strong investment returns should not distract from risk management, operational resilience and long-term insurance planning, adding that early engagement with brokers and insurers would be important.
Gary Field, chief commercial officer at Lockton P.L. Ferrari, said geopolitical risks had become a major factor in marine insurance markets and would influence renewal negotiations over the coming year.
Meanwhile, claims development remained stable and within budget at the halfway point of the current policy year. However, the northern hemisphere winter season could bring further claims volatility, while the Baltimore bridge incident is expected to affect excess-of-loss reinsurance renewals.
Some P&I clubs are also diversifying into other marine insurance products to reduce their exposure to fluctuations in the P&I market. Lockton said it remained to be seen whether these businesses could help stabilise underwriting results.